One comment on “Does Muslim in India and abroad accept Ramdevji’s Anti Cow Slaughter, Birth Control and Anti Terrorist Movement ??”

1. Prakash Das

   November 6, 2009

   

   Did Baba Ramdev read the following news?

   Jamiat upholds fatwa against Vande Mataram

   TNN 4 November 2009, 01:19am IST

   NEW DELHI: In a move likely to spark a political controversy, the Jamiat Ulama-i-Hind on Tuesday endorsed a fatwa issued by the influential Darul Uloom seminary at Deoband that calls on Muslims not to sing Vande Mataram as doing so was violative of Islam’s faith in monotheism.

   The resolution said Muslims were being targeted over the issue and asserted, “We love our country, but cannot elevate it to the status of Allah, the only one worshipped by Muslims… The fatwa of Darul Uloom is correct.” The reference to nation as mother and an ode to motherland was unIslamic and “should not be deliberately raised for causing communal discord and law and order,” the Jamiat said.

   The endorsement from a Jamiat “general session” at Deoband came on a day when the assembly was addressed by home minister P Chidambaram and saw BJP swiftly wading in, claiming the minister’s presence had “legitimised” the “anti-Vande Mataram” view. “We oppose the Jamiat’s resolution,” said BJP leader Murli Manohar Joshi.

   The Jamiat move comes in the backdrop of some states like BJP-ruled Madhya Pradesh introducing singing of Vande Mataram in government-run schools. Endorsing Darul Uloom’s “edict”, the resolution said, “We love our country and have proved it many times, but Vande Mataram violates our faith in monotheism that is the foundation of our faith.”

   BJP vice-president Mukhtar Naqvi said singing Vande Mataram was not compulsory but the manner in which the Jamiat opposed the verses immortalised in Bankim Chandra Chatterjee’s classic was unacceptable. He also targeted Chidambaram for addressing a gathering where the singing of Vande Mataram was opposed saying this would be read as support for the Jamiat’s “retrograde” viewpoint.

   Former Union minister Arif Mohammad Khan wondered about the “provocation” for Deoband’s fatwa, stressing that the objectionable stanzas in the classic, which had idolatrous references to Bharat Mata, do not form part of the national song.

   BSP’s Shahid Siddiqi, however, defended the religious seminary. On the issue of timing, he suggested that it was prompted by a campaign in western UP demanding that Deoband issue a fatwa recommending the national song to Muslims.

   In his address, Chidambaram steered well clear of any controversy, praising the Jamiat for its anti-terrorism resolution adopted at Deoband last year. He said it was a call for all citizens, not just Muslims, to oppose violence and terrorism. He also criticised the demolition of Babri Masjid and said it was the duty of the majority to look after the minorities.

   In other resolutions the Jamiat adopted, it opposed the proposed Central Madrasa Board as an intrusion in the running of madrasas while also saying that education of girls after 10 years of age should be in accordance to “complete Sharia norms.”

   While what Sharia norms would mean is not spelt out by the resolution, it is understood to refer to segregated classrooms and use of veil and hijab. Darul Uloom has repeatedly ruled co-education as unlawful and also did not support a recent ruling of a senior cleric at Cairo’s highly respected Al Azhar that face veils were not required in all-women classrooms.

   Declaring Islam as a religion of peace, the Jamiat said it was opposed to killing of innocents as “unpardonable sin.” It said the effort to make jihad synonymous with terrorism as incorrect. “Jihad is basically a constructive phenomenon… misrepresentation of jihad should be avoided. We condemn suicide bombings and murderous attacks targeted at innocent persons, women, children and elderly,” the resolution said.

   Among the 25 resolutions that were adopted, the Jamiat opposed women’s reservation bill but plugged for quotas for Muslims including marking out separate sub-quotas for Muslim OBCs and treating “labour castes” and “backward classes” among Muslims at par with Dalits by amending Article 341 of the Constitution. The scheduled caste category should be extended to sections like Muslim weavers.

   The resolutions slammed the government for not acting fast enough on Sachar Committee recommendations and the Ranganath Mishra report on alleged discrimination in government selection processes. Another resolution asked the government to bring forward the promised law on communal violence.

   The Jamiat strongly opposed the Delhi High Court ruling legitimising gay sex which it said would lead to “sexual anarchy and recognition of debauchery.”

   The Jamiat declared homosexuality as “unnatural, accursed and deviant behaviour that would irreparably damage social fabric as two people of the same sex were in no way able to contribute to procreation of the human race”.

   As in Deobandi writings, the Jamiat warned against other sects like Qadyani for being “turncoats”, suggesting its own version of Islam was the true and correct one. Calling for professional technical institutions, it said it was necessary for Muslim organisations to take the lead as Muslims who studied professional courses could get cut off from their moorings. It condemned US intervention in Iraq and Afghanistan.

   Then how Ramdevji shared a dias of anti Indian Ulemas of Deoband who cannot accept BANDE MATARAM which is nothing but a basic force of Indian Struggle of Independence ??

   The Muslims of India perform Pranayam without Om. They are patriots without Bande Mataram. They are the champions of Indian Harmony treating all Hindus as Kaffirs. Such type of hegemony exposes the class of Indian Muslims. But Ramdevji relies upon their provisions of Indian-ness under a full poof Islamisations of India. Any one can be purchased by these anti Indian elements at any time. But We believe Ramdevji can not do it. Ramdevji should oppose the fatwa against Bande Mataram. In this way the followers of Swami Ramdevji can uphold the dignity of Bande Mataram aganist the culprit Ulemas of Deoband.

   LikeLike

   Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.